Should AI Do This or Should I?
Should AI do this, or should you? A five-question checklist, a build / buy / delegate / keep scorecard, and a five-task exercise.
Five questions and four lanes — build, buy, delegate, keep human — for deciding what AI should touch. Run the checklist, score the lanes, then take the five-task exercise through your own week.
Start here, verbatim from the stream: recording a 30 minute video, transcribing it, and then taking those ideas and building them into something useful beats having AI create content from a short prompt. The machine multiplies what you feed it — so feed it the good stuff, and decide deliberately what it gets to touch.
The 5 questions
Q1 — Think or remember? (Shukla's test)
Does the task need someone to think, or just remember? Repeating the same steps — reminders, moving a lead into a sheet, notifications — is automation: simpler, cheaper, no surprises. Understanding — drafting, judging, personalizing — is where AI belongs.
Q2 — Is it irreversible?
Messages sent in your name, relationships touched, things published: a human decides, always. My Friday rule, verbatim: I'm gonna go try to do five or 10 of these things, see exactly what happened, fine tune it, work out the kinks, then start adding it. Small supervised cohort first; scale only after trust.
Q3 — Frequency vs upkeep
Daily, stable, boring → automate or buy. Rare, fiddly, identity-shaped (like Ghost Studio) → think hard before building, because you will support it forever: if you build these super apps that support yourself, they can be hyper powerful — at the same time, you have to support them.
Q4 — What does failure cost?
A wrong connection request is cheap and fixable. A wrong message to a first-degree contact is not. Low-risk: let AI run. High-risk: a review queue where you approve before anything sends.
Q5 — Joy and judgment
If doing it yourself keeps your taste sharp — writing, editing, talking to customers — keep it. The premium skill of the next years is quality control of AI output, and you can't control what you've stopped practicing.
Scorecard — try it now
How scoring works: read each lane’s test, then score one real task below. Nothing is saved — your notes are the app.
Build when: core to how you work + no mature tool + worth supporting. Test: would you still fix it at 8am when it breaks? Yes → build.
Buy when: a great tool exists and the job just needs doing (recording, transcription, scheduling). Test: Restream rule — I'm gonna try to restream because it's easy.
Delegate when: reversible, reviewable, trust earned through a supervised cohort first. Test: five supervised runs clean → widen the lane.
Keep human when: irreversible, relationship-bearing, or joy/judgment-forming. Test: would you regret the atrophy? Yes → keep.
The 5-task exercise
List five things you did this week. Run each through Q1–Q5, assign a lane, and publish one result: what moved, and what you took back. That loop — review, learn, hand more off once trusted — is the whole game: it's not set up and forget it. It requires constant monitoring and human intelligence.
This Week on Man vs Machine
The toolkit is one of three pieces this week:
Get the next field note
New articles, show notes, and practical lessons from the Strattegys AI crew.
InsightsAI Safety Has a Capital Allocation Problem
What a conversation with Anthony Monroy and Aligned Institute reveals about sovereignty, open-source AI, and the infrastructure layer missing from AI risk.
FeaturedAre You Paying Attention to Attention Is All You Need?
Eight Google researchers published one 2017 paper, then quit to build companies from it. Here is what the transformer blueprint means for your business.
InsightsBuilding A Spotlight Video From A Live AI Workflow
A Morning Scrum field note on using AI to produce a Strattegys Spotlight package, and building the missing production tools as the work unfolded.
Your brand here
Get represented on the rack.
Get represented on the rack
Inquire about representation — coverage, qualified meetings, and deal support. No plans, no pricing sheets, just a conversation about fit.
